|

Poincare Conjecture – on contribution

There are so many calculations/divisions/guesses/conjectures on who has made the biggest contribution to solve the problem or how much value the Chinese mathematicians has contributed to the final solution, after the news Chinese mathematicians put final pieces in global puzzle – Poincare conjecture came out.

This is a metaphor. Funny.

A Stage Play of the P Conjecture: Perelman vs Cao-Zhu-Yau

送交者: qed 2006年6月06日07:14:02 于 [教育与学术]http://www.bbsland.com

Stage 0: Poincare, the prophet, told people that there exists a tunnel which would go from this side of the mountain to the other side of the mountain.

Stage 1: Poincare announced that he found a mistake and that the tunnel he found could not go through the mountain but maintained his belief that there still exists such a tunnel yet to be found. This conjectured tunnel was then named “Tunnel of Poincare”.

Stage 2: Many pioneers went out trying to find such a tunnel but failed. However, some of them (Stallings, Zeeman, Smale, Freedman) did find similar tunnels in other mountains.

Stage 3: Perelman, the monk, told people that he had found Tunnel of Poincare in the mountain that Poincare himself failed, and that he laid out 30 trail marks at various places in the tunnel so that other people could go through by themselves.

Stage 4: Cao and Zhu were teamed up as an expedition to explore the feasibility of Perelman’s tunnel. They were able to go through indeed and they laid out more than 300 trail marks along the tunnel which eases the pass greatly.

Stage 5: Yau, the king, announced that the ultimate discovery of Poincare Tunnel was finally made by Cao and Zhu, and emphasized the importance of the “Perelman Method” (called by Cao-Zhu “Hamilton and Perelman’s Ricci flow theory”).

Stage 6: Celebration.

A more serious calcualtion. Serious!

送交者: mathjn 2006年6月06日09:44:40 于 [教育与学术]http://www.bbsland.com

You’s better divide Poncare conjecture into 2 parts;
1, high dimension (n>4), proved by S. Smale (and Stalling, but mainly S. Smale);

2, 3-D. In the late 70’s, W. Thurston made his famous geometrization conjecture for 3-M compact manifold. He completely classify 3-D manifold, and proven for a large class of manifolds—-the so-called Haken manifolds. But not general 3-D. His method is topological and some of the details hadn’t been written down until now. (that was why some big guys, such as J.P.Serre, the first winner of the Abel criticize Thurston’s Fields medal). Geometrization conjecture is more generel than Poincare conjecture, the xxxxer includes the latter.

3, 4-D. Mike Freedman proved it in the topological category, but not in the smooth category. S. Donaldson used some idea from Yang-Mills gauge theory (your fileds, hehe, you can say more) found astonishing properties of the smooth 4-D manifolds in the early 80’s. but 4-D is MUCH HARDER than 3-D case. Because for 3-D, at least we had Thurston’s conjecture. But for 4-D, so far, we still have not any even conjecture for the classification of the smooth compact 4-D manifolds. 4-D poincare conjecture is only a special case. BTW, Hamilton’s Ricci Flow is also considered as a way to approach 4-D poincare conjecture.

In my personal opinion. You’d better add between youe stage 2 and 3 R. Hamilton’s work. in 1982, R. Hamilton INVENTED Ricci flow and proved great theorem in 3-D manifold. His method was geometrical analysis, of course S.T.Yau was very interested in. S.T.Yau realized the potential power of the Ricci Flow so he suggested Hamilton try Poincare conjecture. Please note, S.T. Yau could not do Ricci Flow by himself. Because as a Fields medal, he should not join a field which was created by other people—his friend R. Hamilton. What he could do is to support it and ask his students do it. Yau also suggested Hamilton try to find the Harnack property in the Ricci Flow—-the Li-Yau inequality in Ricci Flow. After several hard work, finally, Hamilton found it. In 1995, R. Hamilton propose a great proposal—–in the first time, R. Hamilton raised the “finite time singularities in the Ricci flow”. IN that 100 pages long paper, R. Hamilton propose a way to prove 3-D poincare conjecture. That is why 1996-1997, Yau tried to push Chinese mathematision work in Ricci Flow, because R. Hamilton make the dream of proving 3-D poincare conjecture as a reasonably possibility.

I have to say, R. Hamilton himself can not finish his progrom. Just couldn’t. Becasue in Perelman’s papers, it needed some methods which R. Hamilton did not know. That is why it was G. Perelman win.

I say again, I said it several times: The most important contribution belong to R. Hamilton and G. Perelman, at least 90%!

It is so ridiculous that Yang Le, a person hasn’t been doing research more than 10 years, and knows NOTHING about geometry, he claimed Chinese mathematicion make 30% contribution. It is ridiculous, just ridiculous. Cao-Zhu’s work is great, but is demaged by Yang Le’s stupid words.

Who will get the one million dollar? Does it matter?

Similar Posts

  • About China’s bloggers.

    Some interesting figures here, China now has over 110 million internet users. China has more than 600 blog service providers. About 30% of these internet users update at least one post on their blogs weekly. 博客大战何时休?――网络世界的文化忧思 来源: 新华网 “一亿网民三成博客”的现状,正在让中国进入一个前所未有的“泛话语权”时代。然而,博客近来频频出现不和谐的声音:新老作家、音乐人、文学评论家、相声演员等纷纷上阵,把博客变成了一个争吵不休的是非之地。时下,国内各大网站正大张旗鼓发地起文明办网倡议,“博客热”无疑也需要一些冷思考。  “名人博客”战火纷飞 4月17日公布的《中国电子商务报告(2004-2005年)》显示,目前我国上网用户总数超过1.1亿人。据新浪网介绍,新浪网上每 天会有10万多篇新博客文章出现。1.1亿网民中大约有30%的人每周更新一篇博客。百度的统计显示,截至2005年11月底,我国博客站点服务商超过 600个。 不幸的是,狗年也正在因“博客热”变成一个“名人是非年”“博客诽谤年”。近日,先有“中国博客诽谤第一案”判决,又有红极一时的 相声演员郭德纲与童年伙伴汪洋因博客之争即将对簿公堂。文坛更是被博客搅动得热闹非凡:上海的韩寒先后与文学评论家白烨、作家陆天明、音乐人高晓松就“文 坛是个什么坛”在博客上大打笔仗,最后甚至演变成“口水仗”。 成千上万的网民在多方论战的博客上踊跃评论,更是让这个言论自由的网络空间内“战火纷飞”,骂声四起。 尽管这些“骂仗”现在已纷纷偃旗息鼓,不过,博客中充斥的攻击、谩骂,却让许多人对这一新兴网络传播方式产生了反感。东方卫视主持人、 同样也是博客写手的骆新认为,博客的兴起,正是源于人们需要以更加多元化的思路来表达自己。“但是谁来监督博客的真实性,正在成为一个对公共舆论安全的巨 大挑战。”   博客:道德规范和伦理准则的监管真空 “写博客的人大体有两种心态,一种是自娱自乐型,只选择自己的亲戚朋友作为博客读者,他们的心态比较平和。另一种则是为了吸引社会眼 球,造成舆论影响,在这样的心态下,他们必须不断制造噱头。”新浪网总编辑陈彤认为,对于后一种人来说,写博客就如同网络中的“真人秀”。而名人们齐齐上 阵,使得这样的博客“真人秀”收视率或点击率急速飙升。 事实上,正是名人博客的负面效应、娱乐时代的“真人秀”文化、多元价值观的剧烈碰撞,以及中文博客网站的“监管真空”等等,共同催生了“博客战争”的强大冲击波。 早在2004年11月,中国博客网就曾刊发《博客道德规范倡议书》,指出在博客发表的文字对公众和社会有责任,必须遵循应有的道德规范和伦理准则。但2006年春天蔓延于博客上的攻击谩骂说明,不具备法律效力的“倡议”“规范”收效甚微。…

  • 同样的提问,不同结果

    一次 Claude 检索对比 同一个 Project,几乎一样的提示词,让 Claude 的 Haiku 和 Sonnet 去搜索Project中同同样所有旧对话——结果差挺远。 Project 里有两样东西:多个上传的文件和多组聊天记录。每组对话有对话名称。Sonnet 分得清,直接去搜;Haiku 却一直翻文件,翻不到,就把文件里的标题当成”对话名称”塞给我——没找对地方,还不肯承认没有。我需要改提示词为“历史聊天记录”,Haiku它才能找到结果。 更麻烦的是,它最后那份”完整”清单也不可靠:思考摘要写”四个”,正文却写”五个”,自己都对不上;还有几条只有说明、没有正文,像硬凑的。Sonnet 则干净地给出两个,都带完整内容。 Haiku智商大概10岁,Sonnet已经成年。 Same question, different models, quite a gap (a little Claude test) Same Project, almost the same prompt. I asked two Claudes, Haiku and Sonnet, to dig up all the old conversations on one topic inside that Project….

  • | |

    【转】25个免费英文书库

    免费的中文网上书库有很多。以前零星上过一些免费的英文书库。现在EduChoices来了个总结,不客气,全文转载。 1. The Online Books Page Free Books on the Online Books Page The University of Pennsylvania’s Online Books Page is one of the best places to read free books online. There are more than 30,000 English works available. All of them are formatted nicely and can be read right on your computer. 2. Project…

  • | |

    开始Pop!Tech

    本来答应June做一个Pop!Tech 2007的远程现场直播,可惜在开会前不知什么时候被新加坡的毒蚊子叮了一口,中了登革热。Pop!Tech开会的时候躺在医院里看The Mummy。 这登革热着实够毒,出院还要昏昏沉沉睡了两个多礼拜,到这几天才大致感觉打字写博不是件很累的活。 只是错过了现场直播,看着Pop!Tech网站上那长长的密密麻麻的演讲者列表,一下子又不知道从何写起。 先跟着Pop!Tech的官方博客,想到哪,写到哪吧–感觉有点象自言自语–等找到了对翻译Pop!Tech感兴趣的人再一起系统的写。 对于大部分国人来说,语言是要了解Pop!Tech内容的最大障碍。正好June在10月16号的博文中介绍了Pop!Tech网站尝试解决这个问题走出的一个很有创意的也很有意义的一步。 Pop!Tech与dotSub一起合作推出了八种语言版的Pop!Tech视频播客。 Pop!Tech利用dotSub提供的服务,为视频加上不同语言的字幕。这样Pop!Tech的内容就可以跨过语言障碍,传播到全世界。(点这里可以看到中文版。) 资源有限,现在Pop!Tech只为其中八个视频做了字幕。而且,其中中文的翻译,用桑葚的话说,“比较烂,像是机器翻译的”。 对此,Pop!Tech打算把字幕的翻译用wiki完全开放给用户。现在只好将就一下吧。实在受不了的话也可以在上面留言提提意见,Pop!Tech会很快做出改进。 Pop!Tech是一个开放的团体。

3 Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *